tough love.

by Alexis on June 17, 2010


you know you love me. make sure you get all of me: subscribe to the depressionsandconfessions rss feed, or you can get your alexis fix via e-mail.

yesterday was intense. what with the guest postage at scary mommy and prairie mama, the debate over whether or not ppd is a copout for when you feel like your kids are too annoying, and the fact that i peed approximately 94 times in 18 hours, i barely had a spare second in my day. but today is awkward thursday so all is right with the world.

for those of you who are new to my blog (hi pretties), sorry for the mess around here. i am still in the process of converting to wordpress, so there are nails lying around and chipped paint on the walls and i might have drilled a hole into my hand when i was hanging a picture. but that’s ok, i have another hand, and the construction will be done soon.

awkward thursday is the day when i write about subjects that are frequently stigmatized by society, and have some importance to women. i used to have a nifty little page that had links to all my awkward posts, but that page is currently on vacation in the land of “technology hates alexis and is trying to kill her via a heart attack over the state of her blog.” coincidentally, this is also the land in which my comments are languishing.

a few of my previous awkward topics have been race relations, sleepfarting, nether hair, and my tragic struggle with elephantitis. as you can see, this blog is both well-rounded and undeniably mature.

today i was reading marie claire and i came across an article about how our best friends might be our worst enemies. in the opening paragraph, it talks about this scene in sex and the city (the first movie) when samantha is rationalizing why she dumped smith, who was arguably the best boyfriend anyone could ask for. and he’s hawt. she says that she couldn’t be with him because she “love[d] herself more.”

and instead of telling samantha she was being ridiculous, the girls affirmed her decision and patted her on the back for being so fabulous.

when i watched the movie, i found myself thinking that samantha was an idiot. and now that i’ve read this article, i think her friends were idiots, too.

i have this friend, who i am very close to. if you know me in real life, don’t try to guess who it is because you don’t know her. but she’s dealt with a lot in her life, including a long-term struggle with weight, which led to an eating disorder and what i think is a very skewed self-image. for these and many other reasons, she didn’t really date during her twenties, at least not seriously. she is in her early thirties now, and i’m sure the questions about if she’s ever going to get married are starting to get annoying.

i admit to being one of the people who wondered, “what is this girl waiting for? she needs to find a man and settle down already!” not because i think that’s what every woman needs, but because that’s what i genuinely thought she wanted. i didn’t want her to be lonely or unhappy, and it killed me that she thought she wasn’t good enough for anyone.

so when she started dating someone last year, i was initially ecstatic for her. i’m completely ashamed to admit it, but i thought, “yay! now she will finally get married and have kids and we can complain together!” i encouraged her to date him, and had long conversations with her about the possibilities for her future. but as i came to find out more about their relationship and the guy she was with, i realized that he was a terrible match for her. he was in a serious relationship with someone else, and he was also kind of an ass. a dumbass, if you will.

as soon as i understood just how toxic this person was to my friend, i told her. in no uncertain terms. the word she used to describe my approach was “harsh”; i would call it “honest but really bitchy.” i refused to enable her in making choices that i knew would come back to haunt her later. and i hoped that she was grown-up enough to see that i wasn’t criticizing her, i was trying my best to protect her the only way i knew how.

i haven’t always been a good friend. there have been times when i have backstabbed, sabotaged, and hated on. i have occasionally been jealous of friends’ successes and wished i could be better than them. i’m not proud of those times, and thankfully i left them behind when i got married, grew up and realized i was being a douche. since then, i have tried very hard to be a loyal and honest friend.

i realize that my methods are not for everyone; it’s never fun to be told that you are making bad choices. but i would rather be the ONE person who stood up and said what needed to be said, even at the risk of losing everything, than be one of the many who didn’t tell the truth and allowed something bad to happen.

for example, same friend: like i said, she used to have a weight problem. she was skinny all through high school, then had a rough patch in college and gained a lot of weight. it took her years to get back down to a healthy weight, but she did it. and now she is obsessed with staying that way.

at first, i was so happy that she was finally getting her body back and it was so much more fun to shop with her when she wasn’t always grousing about how nothing fit her. but then i put my good friend hat on and realized that there was something very distressing going on with her.

while i commend her for her determination, i worry about her ability to distinguish healthy from crazy. the yo-yoing, the calorie-slashing, the obsessive weighing; none of that is normal. and i tell her, EVERY SINGLE DAY. i don’t let her talk about being fat when she’s with me. she can do that with other people, but when she’s with me, i don’t want to hear about her jiggles. i’d rather know if she is having a good day, or if anything funny happened to her at work.

people might call me rude. fine, call me rude. but i maintain that the secret to being a good friend is NOT telling them whatever they want to hear. to me, the key to friendship is being a mirror. it is my job to accurately reflect my friends, so they can see themselves clearly and make well-informed decisions. because really, who am i helping if i just agree with everything my friends say? no one.

friendship isn’t about lunch dates and manicures and whether or not to get bangs, or at least not all about those things. it’s about having someone who you can call and say, “hey,” then burst into tears, knowing that she will cry with you and then ask if she can bring you cupcakes.

and for the love, please don’t think i’m saying not to support your friends. yes, PLEASE do. but if you can see that they are doing something they could potentially regret, or if you see that they are stuck in a pattern that they don’t even recognize, it is your responsibility to tell them, even if it means it’ll make to look bad.

and when it comes from the right place, your heart, it’s not criticism. it’s love.

Related Posts with Thumbnails

— Alexis

{ 26 comments… read them below or add one }

KIr June 17, 2010 at 4:18 am

I totally agree…I really do. I have a sister who is obsessed with her weight (and at my current weight…it annoys the piss out of me) and I told her earlier this year, YOU ARE NOT ALLOWED TO complain about being fat in front of me..if you want to see someone who needs to lose 20lbs look no further and you complaining about a size 2 body does NOTHING for my mental health or self esteem..so nope, no bitching to me. It was harsh but done in love and self preservation.

Plus I agree that friendship is more than just shopping and manicures, it’s really knowing someone, really loving someone. I often say that my girl friendships (and I have few IRL) are as passionate, and love filled as my marriage and they should be…I want my GFs to know that I’m their ROCK when no one else is…and I want to feel the same, that no matter what my vanity or heart needs to say..I can say it there. Safely and knowing I’ll be loved, warts and all
I loved this post ..thank you.

Reply

Alexis June 17, 2010 at 8:47 pm

i think that was part of the reason it took me so long to tell her to stop obsessing about her weight. at first, i thought my uneasiness with the subject was just because i am overweight and having a hard time losing. i didn’t want to make it sound like i was jealous or trying to sabotage her efforts. but finally, i had to put my own issues to the side for a moment so i could be a better friend to her.

Reply

ericka @ alabaster cow June 17, 2010 at 6:34 am

so you’re saying i have permission to smack my friends? shh…don’t answer. just go with it.

and who the hey is getting all weird about the ppd issue?? because i have a back hand i’m just waiting to use!!
ericka @ alabaster cow recently posted..HAPPY 1ST ANNIVERSARY ALABASTER COW!My ComLuv Profile

Reply

Alexis June 17, 2010 at 8:51 pm

permission granted. you know i’m always down for friend-smacking.

Reply

Pamela June 17, 2010 at 6:40 am

Here from your discussion post on Sits/ Blog Frog

Reply

Maggie S. June 17, 2010 at 6:55 am

Nicely put.

Reply

Stefanie June 17, 2010 at 7:22 am

Scream it from the rooftops sister.
Stefanie recently posted..who would you rather?My ComLuv Profile

Reply

jade June 17, 2010 at 7:35 am

Read your post at scarymommy and loved it..I need my quiet time too! You tell it like it is AND you’re funny!!

Reply

Alexis June 17, 2010 at 8:53 pm

thanks for stopping by, jade! i try to tell it like it is…mostly because i’m too lazy to be classy and polite, but whatever. some people like it, i guess. :)

Reply

Kristina P. June 17, 2010 at 7:53 am

I think a true friend is someone who is honest, doesn’t coddle, but is kind about you. I think many women tear each other down, under the guise of “honesty.”

I have a friend, who several years ago, became addicted to Xanax. She was living thousands of miles away, but I told her she had a problem, and if she didn’t get help, I was going to call her husband and tell him she was going to kill herself. She was so mad and threatened to never talk to me again. I told her I would rather her be ABLE to never talk to me again, than be dead. She took care of it herself. That’s what friends do.
Kristina P. recently posted..Casual Blogger Conference RoundupMy ComLuv Profile

Reply

Alexis June 17, 2010 at 8:56 pm

i am only mean to my friends to their faces. well, not mean…constructively critical. but i NEVER talk bad about my friends behind their backs. maybe about their boyfriends, but never them. anymore.

Reply

Megan June 17, 2010 at 7:54 am

Nope… real friends are not enabling. They dont try to convince you that he is the right one- when clearly he isnt. They tell you how it is! they tell you when youre being a dip sh!t and making poor choices. They tell you when you need to pull your head out and see the real you in the mirror and not the “fat” you…

Your absolutely right woman!

Reply

Andrea June 17, 2010 at 8:38 am

Great post – it is so true that we need to respect one another enough to tell each other the truth. Sure, we all need a little cheering on now and again, but we also need the real deal. Love it!
Andrea recently posted..Wordless Wednesday ~ News Flash: Champion!My ComLuv Profile

Reply

Untypically Jia June 17, 2010 at 8:43 am

Oh my gosh do I have friends that need to listen to my honesty more. I try my best to be a good friend, and I say things, even when you don’t want to hear them. One of my closest friends fell head over heels for this moron and when she told me that he might be the one, I said, “He’s an idiot and you’re being stupid.” She didn’t speak to me for three months, until he broke her heart and she came crying to me wondering how it all went wrong.

Reply

Kari June 17, 2010 at 1:34 pm

Hi!:)
I just wanted to say, you hang in there kid. I was you back in the day. I’m not almost forty and while things are still sometimes hard. You do learn how to deal with depression. You WILL control it versus the other way. Don’t let people like, whats her name. Truly can’t remember her name she is so irrelevant, get you down. The one thing I learned a long time ago about the net. Is she is the one truly unhappy (trust me). She is so miserable and so unhappy she lashes out. She’ll never admit it but that’s what makes you a stronger woman than her. You keep fighting and keep telling the truth more women need to hear about other women struggling. Whether it is friendship, depression, marriage or parenting. I wish there was more of you when I was a young mother!
Good luck sweetheart!
Kari recently posted..My ComLuv Profile

Reply

Alexis June 17, 2010 at 9:33 pm

oh, she didn’t get me down. i just couldn’t bear the thought of her senseless words influencing someone else. but i will keep preaching!

Reply

Mayhem & Moxie June 17, 2010 at 2:59 pm

God, I adore you. Your honesty and your ability to write what is really on your mind is so freaking awesome. Truly.

I saw your message re your subscribers. Ack! Same thing happened to me. It was awful. We are STILL recovering from it, and it has been almost a year. (Probably not what you want to hear, but tragically true.) Anyways, I am your newest subscriber, so hooray for that.

I am also following you on Google because that is what your biggest fans do.

If there is any other way I can pay homage to you, do let me know.

xo
Francesca
Mayhem & Moxie recently posted..Letters to the Boot: Ode to TechnologyMy ComLuv Profile

Reply

Alexis June 17, 2010 at 9:39 pm

No, that is most definitely NOT what i wanted to hear. but it’s ok, i definitely think it will be worth it when all the kinks are worked out. and I adore YOU. mostly because you asked how you can pay homage to me…

i’m thinking a life-size cardboard cutout of myself. although, myself is a little on the large side right now, so that might be scary. all right, i know–a tattoo of my name (first, middle, and last) on your left asscheek will be perfect.

Reply

Whatever DeeDee Wants June 17, 2010 at 8:50 pm

I think women have a hard time saying what they think instead of what they think others want them to say.
I try to be as honest with my friends and sisters as I can but when the truth hurts them it’s hard! I personally would like the plain truth, even if it hurts.

Reply

Alexis June 17, 2010 at 9:40 pm

i’m with you. i always want the truth, even when it make me cry. because i don’t ever want my friends to think they can’t tell me what’s on their minds.

Reply

Holly June 17, 2010 at 10:53 pm

Great post!!
I have a friend that hates me at the moment for caring enough to be honest. She’ll either get over it and talk again, or she won’t and later realize that I was trying to help her make things better… and regret shunning me for it. *sigh* I don’t have any desire to play Jr High games, anymore. I’m in my 40s for crying out loud! Take me as I am… Love me or leave me… You know the routine… (((HUGS)))
Holly recently posted..CBC’10 Swag Bag Giveaway from MMBMy ComLuv Profile

Reply

c.c. June 18, 2010 at 11:32 am

great post, alexis. i agree with you a hundred percent.
c.c. recently posted..picky’s noteworthy!My ComLuv Profile

Reply

debi9kids June 18, 2010 at 9:54 pm

good for you! I always try to be the person who will tell the truth as well and even had to be the one who told a friend her husband was cheating. UGH Awful but HAD to be done and she is so much better for knowing. (and still a friend)

ps I popped over here from MamaKats Blog Frog :)
Hope your blog gets fixed soon.
debi9kids recently posted..Nothing Like a Visit w/ Family To Warm the SoulMy ComLuv Profile

Reply

Jules June 18, 2010 at 11:55 pm
Diana @Hormonal Imbalances June 19, 2010 at 5:35 pm

My very first comment. :) I thought I would return some of the love.

I <3 this post. For me, it was a bit of a guilt twinger – because I do talk about my friends and I hate that about myself. Especially if they piss me off – you can bet my DH is going to get a full run down of their faults for the next 2 days. Possibly longer.

I need to stop doing that. So thanks for the wake-up call.
Diana @Hormonal Imbalances recently posted..The Cheapening of PPDMy ComLuv Profile

Reply

Kari_beri June 19, 2010 at 8:24 pm

I can’t really remember giving any of my bestfriends the straight up talk because they are all better than me! haha. Man, I miss having my friends around =(. I totally agree that that is what a friend is for. Having a bestfriend tell you what is best would only strengthen my trust in that person instead of destroy it. We all benefit from tough love.

Reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv Enabled

Warning: Invalid argument supplied for foreach() in /home/depressi/public_html/wp-content/plugins/smilies-themer-toolbar/smilies-themer-toolbar.php on line 438

{ 2 trackbacks }

Subscribe without commenting

Previous post:

Next post: